Huge news for Pacers fans! Aaron Nesmith, Indiana’s lockdown defender and sharpshooter, is officially available for Game 4 against the New York Knicks in the Eastern Conference Finals, per ESPN’s Shams Charania. After spraining his right ankle in Game 3’s 106-100 loss on May 25, 2025, Nesmith’s return is a massive boost for the Pacers, who lead the series 2-1. Let’s break down why Nesmith’s availability could swing this pivotal game and keep Indy’s NBA Finals dreams alive.
Nesmith’s Gritty Comeback
Nesmith rolled his ankle in the third quarter of Game 3, landing awkwardly on Jalen Brunson’s foot during a baseline drive. He limped off, visibly in pain, and was initially questionable to return. Despite a “noticeable limp” post-game, per ESPN’s Tim Bontemps, Nesmith gutted it out, re-entering in the fourth for seven minutes. His stats were quiet—8 points, 7 rebounds, 2 steals, 1 block—but his presence was felt, especially defending Brunson, who shot just 3-of-11 with Nesmith on the floor. Now, cleared for Game 4 on May 28, 2025, Nesmith’s toughness is a game-changer.
Why Nesmith Is Indiana’s Secret Weapon
Nesmith’s playoff numbers—15.1 PPG, 6.2 RPG, 52.3% FG, 53.5% 3PT—make him a two-way force. His Game 1 explosion (30 points, 8-of-9 threes) sparked a comeback win, and his defense on Brunson has forced 7 turnovers in the series. Without Nesmith, Indy’s depth takes a hit; backups like Bennedict Mathurin (2-of-8 in the series) and Ben Sheppard can’t match his impact. His 43.1% 3PT shooting this season and ability to guard elite scorers like Brunson make him indispensable. With the Pacers favored by 2.5 points at home (per DraftKings), Nesmith’s return keeps their 3-1 series lead hopes alive.
What’s at Stake in Game 4
The Knicks clawed back in Game 3, erasing a 20-point deficit behind Karl-Anthony Towns’ 20 fourth-quarter points. Nesmith’s availability could flip the script, locking down Brunson and stretching New York’s defense with his shooting. Coach Rick Carlisle called him “sore but cleared,” signaling Nesmith’s ready to battle. Can he repeat his Game 1 heroics?
